Nutrition researcher Kevin Hall, PhD submitted a new study for publication that some scientists believe disproves the “carbohydrate-insulin model” of obesity. But the study doesn’t truly support that conclusion.

First, I need a disclaimer. This study hasn’t been published yet. In fact, it hasn’t even been accepted for publication yet.

Normally I wouldn’t write about an unpublished study as many things can change during the peer review process. However, given the stature of Hall and the wave of interest on social media with confusing conclusions, I felt this one deserved immediate attention, despite not having gone through peer review yet.

I have several issues with this study, but the biggest is the misperception that it “proves” the carbohydrate-insulin model of weight gain is false. The study does nothing of the sort.

Dr. Hall and colleagues recruited 20 young (average age 29) individuals without diabetes to live in a metabolic ward for four weeks. For two weeks they ate either a plant-based, low-fat diet consisting roughly of 10% fat, 75% carbs and 15% protein, or an animal-based, low-carb diet of 10% carbs, 76% fat and 14% protein. After two weeks they switched over to the other diet.

The study provided twice as much food as subjects “should” eat, based on their resting energy requirements, and allowed the subjects to choose how much to eat and when to stop. Researchers provided three meals per day, plus continuously available snacks.

The study showed that the subjects ate significantly fewer calories on the low-fat diet than the low-carb diet. Based on that main conclusion, the authors concluded that we don’t gain weight because of carbs and insulin.

I am not sure those are related, however. Let me explain.

First of all, the low-carb group lost more weight despite eating more calories. Wouldn’t that suggest insulin IS important for weight loss?

Eating more calories while losing more weight certainly suggests the number of calories wasn’t the determining factor for weight gain. So what was? Insulin is a very strong contender. Granted, much of the initial weight loss was water weight, which highlights an even bigger problem with the study.

Two weeks is woefully inadequate to measure the effect of a low-carb diet. I was fortunate enough to interview Dr. David Ludwig, a Harvard University obesity researcher, about this study, and he reminded me of an article he wrote in 2017 detailing how the science shows that we likely need four weeks to adapt to low-carb diets, and possibly even longer. Dr. Ludwig also agrees that the primary outcome of this new study has nothing to do with proving or disproving the importance of insulin on long-term weight gain or loss.

In fact, the current study’s results confirm that a two-week study is inadequate to show any meaningful conclusions. In what way? Well, those eating a low-carb diet reduced their caloric intake by 312 calories after the first week. Would calorie consumption have continued to decrease over time? We won’t know because the trial was too short to show us possibly the most important data — what happens to these dieters over time.

What are some potential reasons why the low-fat dieters ate less in the beginning? For one, they had 60 grams of fiber compared to only 20 grams in the low-carb group. Fiber is known to be particularly satiating.

Another potential reason is that the low-carb diet sourced just 14% of its calories from protein. There is debate in the low-carb community about the satiating effects of fat versus protein, but the science seems fairly clear that protein has a greater satiating effect. That is why at Diet Doctor, most of our low-carb and keto recipes contain at least 20% of calories from protein.

Also lost in the fine print is the fact that the low-fat snacks were comprised of 15% protein whereas the low-carb snacks had only 9%. Why the difference?

Significantly, the subjects had much better glucose numbers on the low-carb diet, and they had greater resting energy expenditure, burning an extra 166 kcal per day.

To me, these data suggest that a longer study could have shown greater weight loss from the low-carb group. If the subjects’ resting energy expenditure is higher and they continued to decrease their caloric intake as they adapted to the low-carb diet, greater weight loss would almost certainly follow. But again, since the study was so short and thus limited in scope, we won’t get to see that data.

The study also brings up the important concept of energy density, and calls into question whether fat, especially liquid fat, is particularly satiating, or if it is just a dense, high-calorie fuel. At Diet Doctor, we believe the most satiating meals are low in carbs, include adequate protein and low-carb veggies, and use fat for flavor and extra calories as needed.

As a closing argument, let me summarize by rephrasing the conclusions of this study a different way:

“Low-carb dieters lose more weight despite eating more calories. In addition, they have greater blood glucose control, their resting energy expenditure is higher, and their caloric intake decreases over time.”

Does that sound like a “take down” of the carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity?

Quite the opposite. That sounds like a victory for the importance of carbs, glucose and insulin. Once again, we can see how a reader’s viewpoint can affect how they interpret the data.

Thanks for reading,
Bret Scher, MD FACC


Bad science is bad science, no matter what the conclusions

Obesity as a risk factor for coronavirus complications

Are all diets the same for weight loss and cardiac risk?

Start your FREE 30-day trial!

Get delicious recipes, amazing meal plans, video courses, health guides, and weight loss advice from doctors, dietitians, and other experts.

Join now

Weight lossHow to maximize fat burning03:52Dr. Fung’s fasting course part 2: How do you maximize fat burning? What should you eat – or not eat?“I’ll do this or I’m going to die trying”19:23Kristie Sullivan struggled with her weight for her whole life in spite of trying every diet imaginable, but then she finally lost a 120 pounds and improved her health on a keto diet.The 5 common mistakes on LCHF09:25Is it hard to reach your goal weight, are you hungry or do you feel bad? Make sure you’re avoiding these mistakes.My success story with Kenneth Russell02:52When Kenneth turned 50, he realized that he wouldn’t make it to 60 the way he was going.My success story with Chuck Hicks02:39At nearly 500 lbs (230 kg) Chuck could barely move at all anymore. It wasn’t until he found a keto diet that thing started to change.The pathways of insulin resistance30:41Are we chasing the wrong guy when it comes to heart disease? And if so, what is the real culprit in the disease?Living low carb with Yvonne Lane05:51Yvonne used to see all those pictures of people who’d lost so much weight, but sometimes didn’t really believe they were real.Pie-making champion goes low carb03:23Learn how this pie-making champion went low carb and how it changed his life.Carb-Loaded1:14:40This may be the best (and funniest) low-carb movie ever. At least it’s a strong contender.How to motivate your patients50:25In this presentation from Low Carb Denver 2019, Drs. David and Jen Unwin explain how physicians can finetune the art of practicing medicine with strategies from psychology to help their patients reach their goals.The cause of obesity38:45What is the real cause of obesity? What causes weight gain? Dr. Jason Fung at Low Carb Vail 2016.Are all calories the same?20:04Are all calories created equally – regardless of whether they come from a low-carb, low-fat or a vegan diet?The hidden costs of medications44:51Can medications prevent or hinder your efforts to lose weight and become healthy? Jackie Eberstein at the Low Carb Cruise 2016.Insulin toxicity — Dr. Jason Fung’s diabetes course09:03Dr. Fung looks at the evidence on what high levels of insulin can do to one’s health and what can be done to lower insulin naturally.How to think about how to eat — Gary Taubes30:34In this presentation from the Low Carb Denver conference, the amazing Gary Taubes talks about the conflicting dietary advice we are given and what to make of it all.Is obesity caused by too much insulin?25:27Is obesity mainly caused by the fat storing hormone insulin? Dr. Ted Naiman answers this question.Diet Doctor Podcast #35 with Ben Bikman, PhD00:00Why is insulin so important for us to control and why does a ketogenic diet help so many people? Professor Ben Bikman has studied these questions in his lab for years and he is one of the foremost authorities on the subject.What to do instead of counting calories16:02Why is counting calories useless? And what should you do instead to lose weight?My success story with Jim Caldwell02:23Jim Caldwell has transformed his health and gone from an all-time high at 352 lbs (160 kg) to 170 lbs (77 kg.A global food revolution34:30The mistakes behind the obesity epidemic and how we can fix them together, empowering people everywhere to revolutionize their health.Part 7 of Dr. Jason Fung’s diabetes course05:01Dr. Fung gives us a comprehensive review of what causes fatty liver disease, how it affects insulin resistance and, what we can do to reduce fatty liver.80 pounds lighter and no medications09:12Is it possible to reverse your diabetes with the help of a strict low-carb diet? Definitely, and Stephen Thompson did it.Q&A with Franziska Spritzler09:52Questions about how to formulate an optimal low-carb or keto diet.Therapeutic fasting46:09What if there was a more effective treatment alternative for obesity and type 2 diabetes, that is both simple and free?

The post Unpublished study challenges the insulin model of obesity appeared first on Diet Doctor.

Read more: